Re: Trade?

Trade Discussion

Trade?

---

Anonymous 10-24-2007, 10:26 PM
My Roster looks like this:

Kitna, Romo, Griese

Marion Barber, Addai, Lynch, Selvin Young

Terrell Owens, DJ Hackett, Calvin Johnson, Steve Smith, Wes Welker, Andre Davis

Donald Lee

Random D

Nick Folk

A trade was offered to me for Lynch and Smith, and I would get Brees, Maurice-Jones Drew, and Lee Evans in return

Re: Trade?

---

Anonymous 10-24-2007, 10:26 PM
oh, and I start

1 qb

3 rb

4 wr

1 te

1 d

1 k

Re: Trade?

---

hotsauce18433 10-25-2007, 9:24 AM
No way.  You're never going to start Brees over Romo (who is on a BYE this week), so the trade is essentially 2 for 2.  I love Lynch and think that MJD would be a downgrade at the position due to Fred Taylor continuing to steal carries from a would-be stud.  Smith is not as good as he should be without Delhomme but he is still pretty good.  Evans is a nice player but he is not better than Steve Smith. 

Re: Trade?

---

The Potato King 10-25-2007, 2:03 PM
Agreed. MJD has a tweaked knee as well this week.

Lee Evans has been inconsistent or nonexistant, good showing last week, but Buffalo is a run first team. Once the weather turns to crap Lynch is gonna get all the touches.

Romo is your clear cut QB for the rest of the season, heads and shoulders above the other guys on your roster (and Brees).

I think Brees will have a good second half of the season, but no reason to give up Lynch and Smith for MJD and Evans, especially if you can only start one QB.

Hopefully Carr will stay healthy enough to throw the ball to Smith. Carr, while not a great QB, was still able to get Andre Johnson the ball on a regular basis in Houston.